Who Is the Possible Suspect in the Case of Savannah Guthrie's Missing Mother?

What began as a missing person case has become a full-blown criminal investigation — and shifting details about who last saw her are raising new concerns.

The quiet desert night ended in uncertainty and dread for the Guthrie family. What was first believed to be a simple goodbye after a family dinner has now become a haunting focal point in a growing mystery surrounding Savannah Guthrie's missing mother.

The talk show host's sister, Annie Guthrie, was initially thought to be the last person to see their mother, Nancy Guthrie — a belief that shaped the early hours of a rapidly unfolding investigation and cast a heavy shadow over the family's final moments together.

A Routine Evening That Took a Dark Turn

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos told Us Weekly that Nancy, 84, had been dropped off at her home between 9:30 and 9:45 p.m. on Saturday, January 31, after spending the evening having dinner with family.

At first, investigators believed Annie was the one who brought her mother home that night, a detail that seemed straightforward — until it wasn't. New reports later revealed that it was not Annie who dropped Nancy off, but Annie's husband, Tommaso Cioni. That development has added a troubling new layer of scrutiny to the case.

The revelation has shifted attention and raised questions as authorities continue piecing together Nancy's final known hours. Cioni and Annie were photographed for the first time recently since Nancy was reported missing. However, their body language spoke volumes.

In images obtained by Page Six, the couple appeared to avoid attention while leaving their Tucson residence. Annie wore a pink hoodie pulled tightly over her face, while Cioni concealed his own features with a sweatshirt and dark sunglasses — a visual that only deepened the air of unease surrounding the case.

A Shocking Discovery the Next Morning

Nancy was reported missing on Sunday, February 1, the following morning when she failed to appear for church. Her absence immediately alarmed her loved ones.

Family members went to her home to check on her — and what they found was enough to prompt a frantic 911 call. Inside, there were disturbing signs of a struggle, and authorities later confirmed that blood was found within the residence.

Her home, located in the usually tranquil Catalina Foothills area, was swiftly declared a crime scene, with evidence of forced entry sending shockwaves through the tight-knit community. Authorities have not publicly named any suspects, and investigators say they are continuing to follow all leads as the case unfolds.

A Presidential Call Amid Mounting Fear

As the mystery surrounding Nancy's disappearance deepens, the case has now drawn the attention of the highest office in the nation. President Donald Trump called Savannah on Wednesday. This was a day after publicly offering federal assistance in the search for her missing mother.

A White House official confirmed the call but declined to provide further details about the conversation. Despite their well-documented clashes during the 2020 campaign, the President expressed sympathy for the family's ordeal.

"I think it's terrible," the president said Tuesday. "Very unusual situation, but we're going to find out." He added that he had always "got along very good with Savannah," despite their past disagreements — a striking show of unity amid a personal crisis.

Meanwhile, authorities continue to pursue multiple angles in search of Nancy. Police confirmed signs of forced entry and a violent struggle inside the residence, along with biological evidence linked to Nancy.

Sheriff Chris reiterated that the case is being handled as a criminal investigation, not a missing-persons search. "Somebody came into that home, and I believe took her out there without her permission. It was against her will," he said.

Ransom Notes, Bitcoin Demands, and the FBI

Sources familiar with the investigation told The Post that detectives are narrowing their focus to individuals known to the Guthrie family — a shift that has raised fresh alarm.

At the same time, ransom notes demanding millions in bitcoin have surfaced, including messages sent to media outlets and to Savannah. Officials are still weighing whether the crime was financially motivated or driven by something far more personal.

Some of the messages reportedly referenced details consistent with elements of the crime scene. The FBI has stepped in to assist with analyzing the communications — a move that signals just how serious and complex the case has become.

Tensions escalated further after journalist Ashleigh Banfield cited an unnamed law enforcement source who allegedly named Savannah's brother-in-law, Tommaso Cioni, as a possible suspect.

The Pima County Sheriff's Department quickly pushed back, stating, "We have not identified a suspect or person of interest in this case," while emphasizing that the investigation remains ongoing.

Authorities also denied Ashleigh's claim that a vehicle connected to Tommaso had been seized, saying they were "unsure where that reporter is getting that information."

A Suspicious Stranger and Destroyed Cameras

Adding yet another troubling layer, a neighbor reported seeing a suspicious man trespassing near Nancy's neighborhood several weeks before her disappearance. The incident occurred less than 10 minutes from her home and has since been forwarded to detectives for further review.

In a particularly disturbing detail, all surveillance cameras around Nancy’s property were reportedly destroyed — a devastating setback that has deprived investigators of potential footage from the critical hours before or during the alleged abduction.

As the search enters its fifth day, the normally serene Catalina Foothills community is reeling. Residents describe a neighborhood frozen in fear and disbelief following the sudden disappearance of the 84-year-old woman.

"We're in shock," said Jeff Lamie, a 59-year-old neighbor who has lived in the area for years. "This is really shocking. We just hope that she returns safely." Nancy was last seen Saturday night and reported missing the following morning after failing to attend her regular church service.

According to Jeff, the church was "a big part of her life," and a place where she was known and cherished. Neighbors recall her as a vibrant, familiar presence. "She was active. We would see her driving," Jeff said. "She seemed engaged. We'd see her in the front yard, and she seemed very happy."

As prayers continue and residents double-check security cameras and coordinate with neighborhood watch groups, the emotional toll is unmistakable.