A Banner Reading 'Welcome Home, Cheater!' Appeared Outside Our House One Day, but the Real Shock Was Who Wrote It and Why — Story of the Day

I thought I had the perfect marriage, until lipstick stains and perfume on Tim’s shirts made me question everything. But nothing prepared me for the day I stepped outside and saw a giant banner on our porch screaming: 'Welcome Home, Cheater!'

People used to say Tim and I were the couple everyone envied. We laughed easily, held hands without thinking, and even after ten years of marriage, he still surprised me with flowers or silly little gifts.

I never cared about money. I was a teacher, happy with my modest salary, and never asked Tim for anything. He gave what he wanted, and I cherished it.

But his mother never believed that. Gabriel was convinced I had married her son for his income.

And who could have known that when the first real cracks appeared in our marriage, Gabriel would suddenly stand by my side?

I wasn’t paranoid, not the jealous type. Yet after Tim’s promotion and the young secretary that came with it, something changed. Business trips multiplied, excuses piled up.

And then came the red flags.

Lipstick on Tim's collar. A whiff of sweet perfume clung to his jacket. The faint shimmer of glitter on his sleeve.

“Coincidences,” Gabriel said, shaking her head.

“Coincidences?” I muttered to myself, folding his shirt with trembling fingers. “What woman accidentally leaves red lipstick on a married man’s collar?”

But Gabriel comforted me. “Don’t torture yourself, Cynthia. He’s working hard. Hotels, parties, endless handshakes... It happens. Don’t imagine the worst.”

And yet one night, as I passed by the living room, I overheard her on the phone with Tim. Her voice was sharp, scolding:

“You’d better value your marriage, young man. Do you hear me? You have a wife who stands by you. Don’t make a fool of her.”

That gave me hope. Maybe she really was on my side.

My mother had died when I was a girl, and I had always missed that protective warmth. Gabriel, against all odds, began to feel like the mother I had lost.

Still, doubt gnawed at me. The evening before Tim's next trip, I confronted him.

“You’re leaving again?”

“Yes.”

“With her?”

He sighed. “What kind of question is that?”

“A normal one, Tim! You came back last time with lipstick on your collar.”

“For God’s sake, Cynthia, not again.”

“And your jacket smelled of Chanel. Not mine.”

“You don’t trust me at all, do you? She’s my assistant. She handles the meetings, the schedules. I need her there.”

“Need her,” I repeated bitterly.

He stepped closer and kissed my cheek coldly.

“I’m tired of your interrogations. I expected support, not suspicion.”

And with that, he lifted the suitcase and walked out. I stood there frozen. My chest felt hollow, my thoughts spiraling.

Was I losing him? Or had I already lost him?

Unable to bear it, I grabbed the phone and dialed Gabriel.

“Please… I can’t do this alone. Will you come?”

Her answer was immediate, almost tender. “Of course, darling. I’ll be right there.”

I pressed the phone to my lips after hanging up. At least someone was on my side. At least Gabriel would keep me from falling apart. I had no idea then what a terrible mistake I was making.

***

The days with Gabriel flew by quickly. She was unexpectedly sweet, making me tea and talking about anything but my worries.

“Darling, it will be fine,” she said gently, patting my hand. “Whatever happens, I’ll always be on your side.”

I almost believed her. Maybe she was finally starting to accept me as her son’s wife, maybe even as her own daughter.

When Tim came home from his trip, I ran to him, wrapped my arms around him tightly. I breathed in, terrified of what I might smell — but… nothing. No perfume, no lipstick marks, nothing.

A shaky breath of relief escaped me.

See, Cynthia, don’t be paranoid.

But Tim's expression was dark.

“What the hell is this?” he barked, pushing past me.

“What?”

“The writing on the house! How dare you hug me as if nothing happened?”

My stomach dropped. “What writing?”

“You know damn well what writing!” He jabbed a finger toward the door. “Are you insane? Did you put that there to humiliate me?”

I hadn’t expected anything like that. My chest tightened as I rushed out the front door. And there it was. A massive banner hanging right above our porch, the words painted in bold, angry red: 'WELCOME HOME, CHEATER!'

“Oh God…” I whispered. “Who would do this?”

Tim sneered. “You’re sick. A paranoid lunatic.”

I stumbled back as if he had slapped me.

“What…? What did you just call me?”

Gabriel’s voice cut through. “Timothy James, how dare you speak to your wife like that? We were inside all morning, drinking tea together. That sign wasn’t her doing. Someone else put it there!”

“Then who, Mother? Who would do this?”

“That’s what I’d like to know,” she said, folding her arms. “But maybe you should ask yourself if there’s something you’re not telling us.”

He glared at both of us. “For the last time, there’s no affair! I don’t have a mistress! And the two of you— you’re both driving me insane. Stay out of my face.”

I had never seen him like that. My throat burned, but I couldn’t find an answer.

When Tim stormed upstairs to take a shower, I walked outside in silence. The banner was huge, strung right across our front porch. The letters blazed in red paint: 'WELCOME HOME, CHEATER!'

My hands shook as I tore it down. Neighbors must have seen it. Everyone must have seen it.

My cheeks burned with shame.

Who would do such a thing? It was clearly directed at my husband, but why? To ruin him? To ruin us?

Later, when I dragged the banner out to the trash, my mind still spun with questions. I went upstairs, intending to collapse into bed. Tim was still in the shower.

That’s when I noticed something. Something red was peeking out of his briefcase.

Curiosity turned my blood cold. I stepped closer, my fingers trembling as I pulled it free.

A piece of lace. Red lace.

“Oh God…”

I held it up in disbelief. They weren’t just stockings or a scarf. They were panties. Beneath them lay a folded note.

Can’t wait for our next trip, boss. XOXO, your loyal assistant.

The room tilted. My knees nearly buckled.

“That witch!” I hissed under my breath. “It’s her. It has to be her.”

Rage surged through me, hotter than anything I had ever felt. My patience had snapped. I wasn’t going to wait around anymore.

I was going to confront that little secretary myself. And I already knew where she lived. Tim once dropped her off after a late meeting, and I had memorized the address.

I marched out the door, fury burning through my veins.

The doorbell rang just as I was about to storm out, red lace clenched in my fist. My pulse hammered. I yanked the door open, and there she was. Tim’s secretary, standing on our porch, clutching a folder of documents.

“You,” I hissed.

“Hi! I’m sorry to drop by unannounced. Tim forgot to sign these contracts before the trip, and the office needs them back tonight—”

Before she could finish, I hurled the panties at her.

“You think you’re clever?! Leaving your trash in my husband’s bag? Writing filthy little notes like this?”

I waved the crumpled paper in her face. Her eyes went wide.

She stumbled back, clutching the lace as if it were venomous. “What?! No! I swear, I don’t know how—”

“How dare you show up here after ruining my marriage!” Hot tears spilling down my cheeks. “You shameless little—”

From inside, Gabriel’s voice called, “Cynthia? What’s going on?”

The shouting had already drawn her out. She stepped onto the porch, her face painted with false concern.

“Oh dear, what’s all this noise?”

The secretary spun toward her, trembling with outrage.

“Madam, tell her the truth!” Her voice rose, desperate. “You came to my house last week, remember? You brought a pie for my son because he was sick. You know I didn’t travel with your son. I stayed home with my family. I have my own husband, my child! Tell her!”

I turned slowly to Gabriel.

“Is that true?”

Gabriel’s lips twisted into a thin line. “I… I don’t recall.”

“You don’t recall?!” the secretary exploded. “Why are you lying? You even asked to use the bathroom upstairs, where our laundry was drying. And... Oh my God! These panties! You didn’t just lie… You stole them!”

“That’s ridiculous, I’d never touch your laundry.”

My hand flew to my mouth. “Oh God… And the note…” My eyes burned as I stared at the crumpled paper. “That’s your handwriting!”

Gabriel suddenly turned her gaze on me, her voice sickly sweet.

“Cynthia, darling, I am your only friend here. It’s time to face the truth — my son has been cheating on you. Stop torturing yourself and just file for divorce.”

“Divorce…” The word tore out of me like a scream. My head spun as the pieces fell together. “That’s what you’ve been pushing for all along? The lipstick… the perfume…” My voice rose in horror. “Oh God, it was your Chanel I smelled on the jacket! And the lipstick—your shade!”

“Well, well. Looks like the game is up. Finally, you’re not as stupid as you look.”

Gabriel’s mask cracked.

“Mom?” Tim’s voice boomed from the doorway. He had come down, hair wet from the shower, towel draped around his shoulders. “What the hell is going on here?”

Gabriel ignored him. Her eyes locked on me.

“You really are naïve, Cynthia. Did you honestly think I would ever love you? From the moment you married my son, I knew you were wrong for him. A schoolteacher with nothing to offer but pretty smiles.”

“All this time… all those kind words…”

“They were an act. I wanted you gone. What better way than to make you doubt him? A little lipstick here, a bit of perfume there. And finally, the perfect touch.”

“That’s disgusting, Gabriel!” the secretary shouted.

Gabriel flicked her hand toward the lace. “Almost worked, didn’t it? If it weren’t for her ruining everything—”

Tim’s face went pale. “You? Mother… you did all this?!”

She lifted her chin defiantly. “I did what had to be done. You deserve better.”

“No!” His voice shook with fury. “You humiliated me. You nearly destroyed my marriage. Get out.”

“Timothy—”

“I said, get out!”

For the first time, Gabriel faltered. Her eyes darted between us, searching for support she no longer had. With a sharp, bitter laugh, she stalked down the driveway.

Silence crashed over us. Then, the secretary pressed the documents into my hand, muttering softly, “I’m sorry you had to go through this,” before hurrying away.

Finally, Tim turned to me.

“Cynthia, honey… I’m so sorry. I should have trusted you, should have seen what she was doing. Please… forgive me. No more endless trips. I’ll be here with you. With us.”

All I could do was collapse into his arms, clutching him as if he might vanish.

Tell us what you think about this story, and share it with your friends. It might inspire them and brighten their day.

If you enjoyed this story, read this one: I thought my father’s will would secure my future. Then the lawyer read a name I didn’t recognize. My grandmother’s fury was immediate. Who was Brenna, and why did my father leave her everything? And what secret was behind it? Read the full story here.

This story is a work of fiction inspired by real events. Names, characters, and details have been altered. Any resemblance is coincidental. The author and publisher disclaim accuracy, liability, and responsibility for interpretations or reliance. If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.